Spider conducted extensive tests to analyze how two of the major
search providers performed under certain controlled conditions-the browser used
was Google chrome in incognito mode, and the internet speed of a steady
1500kbps of dedicated bandwidth. To ensure neutrality, we turned off search
suggestions and cleared the cache for each query, to avoid results being
affected by the image, video, blogs, news, shopping, reference/academic
(dictionary, encyclopedia, maps). The table below represents the sum of the
results of Spider’s tests. The results of the tests reflect searches made on a
particular day and the state of the search provider’s index on that day-which
may change as time passes.
GOOGLE
|
BING
|
||
Basic Search
|
83
|
54.5
|
Out of 100
|
Vague Search
|
73.33
|
41.33
|
Out of 100
|
Regional Relevance
|
4
|
2
|
Out of 5
|
Semantic Search
|
4.5
|
3.3
|
Out of 5
|
From the aggregate scores for Google and Bing, Google is
clearly the better search performer of the two. But that’s a rather macroscopic
view of their individual performances. While the generalization holds true,
with Google scoring two nearly perfect results according to our tests, there
were certain things Bing performed extremely well at, which we will discuss in
our next blog. The one thing we held as a rule, was that what mattered to a
search user would be results, and not the technologies behind the search.
No comments:
Post a Comment